Maybe love is the best reason to rethink your convictions

Not that long ago, a friend came out of the closet to me. At first, I wasn’t sure what to say. I knew it wasn’t my place to express an opinion on the moral legitimacy of same-sex relationships, especially when I wasn’t even sure what I believed about that anymore.

What I did know was that I cared about my friend. I owed it to them — and myself — to reconsider what I had always assumed by default to be true, to make sure I’d thought this through, listened to the other side, considered all possibilities. That’s something I’d never really done before.

In the end, what motivated my decision to reconsider wasn’t some big epiphany. It was a friend.

Courtesy Spencer E Holtaway

Recently, when Facebook announced it was offering 51 additional gender identities for people to choose from, conservative pundits reacted with predictable outrage. But even some of us who aren’t conservative were probably tempted to roll our eyes at the news.

Then a friend on Facebook started using one of the 51 new options. Suddenly it didn’t seem like PC sensitivity run amok. To my friend, it meant safety. Validation. Reassurance they were OK even if they didn’t fit neatly into one of the only two categories previously available to them.

Photo by ChodHound on Flickr

I’m not saying all of this is simple. Figuring out what you should believe isn’t always an easy task. But our first (and perhaps only) response to someone who is gay or who identifies according to a gender category we’ve never even heard of… well, let me suggest that part IS simple.

If our first impulse is anything other than to love, embrace, and accept the other person as they are, then we have missed the boat.  

You might say I’m being overly simplistic. You might argue this kind of acceptance only encourages people down a destructive path.

Set aside for a moment the question of whether loving someone of the same gender or identifying as “non-binary” on Facebook causes actual harm to someone. That’s a debatable assumption at best. The real problem with any other response is that you start to see issues instead of people. You begin treating loved ones as problems to be solved, instead of divine image-bearers who were made to be cherished.

Well, I’m done viewing others as problems that need to be fixed.

AFP, Isaac Kasamani

If you want to know where treating people as problems gets you, just look at Uganda.

The president of Uganda just signed a bill to solve the “problem” of homosexuality in his country. The law makes homosexuality punishable by life imprisonment in some cases. It requires citizens to denounce anyone they suspect of being gay.

One Ugandan newspaper wasted no time complying with that last provision, publishing a list of “200 top homos.” The last time a paper did this in Uganda, the names and addresses were run under the headline “Hang Them.” A gay rights campaigner was bludgeoned to death.

Defending the Bill, Uganda’s minister for ethics and integrity, Simon Lokodo, described gays as “beasts of the forest.” To him, homosexuality is a disease to be cured. Lokodo has even suggested that heterosexual child rape is preferable to consensual sex between two male adults.

That’s where you end up when you start viewing members of the LGBT community — or anyone else, for that matter — as problems to be solved rather than people to be loved.

—//—

I used to look down on those who started questioning longstanding beliefs, all because they knew someone who was gay. I used to think the strength of your convictions was measured by your willingness to hold them no matter what the fallout, no matter how much hurt they caused.

Then I remembered that “love does no harm to a neighbor.” I remembered that the FIRST thing we should see in someone else is the divine imprint, the image of God staring back at us.

Whatever your beliefs may be, if you don’t start here, then there’s no way to get it right.

Maybe caring about a friend is one of the best reasons you could have to reevaluate your convictions.

[Photo credits: Spencer E Holtaway, ChodHound on Flickr, Isaac Kasamani/AFP]

9 thoughts on “Maybe love is the best reason to rethink your convictions

  1. Beautifully written. Thank you for your honesty and your willingness to reevaluate your convictions and challenge others to do so, as well.

    I personally affirm and support my LGBTQ brothers and sisters who seek same-sex relationships, marriages, ordination, etc. However, I love what you say: wherever people personally stand on these “issues,” we must first and foremost love ALL people as fellow humans and as “divine image-bearers who were made to be cherished” rather than as “problems to be solved.”

    These words are so powerful:
    “If you want to know where treating people as problems gets you, just look at Uganda…That’s where you end up when you start viewing members of the LGBT community — or anyone else, for that matter — as problems to be solved rather than people to be loved.”

    I am still trying to swallow this bill.

    God, have mercy on us all!

    • Thanks Emily. It took me a while, but eventually I came to the same place of affirmation and support as you. Considering where I started out (even working at one point for one of the more hostile anti-gay organizations out there), I’m grateful to be in a different place today. And it’s in no small part because of friends like the one I mentioned at the beginning of this piece. Anyway, that’s what motivates me to reach out to people on the other side of the “issue.” I was lucky enough to have people in my life who believed I could change, so I have to believe others can change their perspective too…

      • Wow. It is wonderful to hear how far you have come from such a different place. I have many beloved friends who are on all ends of the spectrum on this “issue,” and I, too, was once a part of a college ministry that led me to the “other side” for a while. I think our experiences can be excellent tools for us in conversations like these: these experiences can enable us to empathize with where people with differing perspectives are coming from and yet discern how and when to speak up when it is necessary in challenging and yet respectful ways.

        Thank you for continuing to be such a prophetic voice on a variety of difficult and controversial topics. Your voice is powerful and needs to be heard!

  2. Ben you’ve done an excellent job of walking a tightrope on this one:) I can identify with your struggles and you came to the right conclusion. The answer is love. It’s not our place to judge, especially if we don’t wish to be judged.

  3. very well written, when an “issue” becomes personal it does cease to be something external and the only way to deal with it is to dig deep inside one’s beliefs and conviction – it is being human

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s